Reading ➷ Verdicts on Nehru: The Rise and Fall of A Reputation (e-Single) Author Ramachandra Guha – Online-carhire-spain.co.uk

Verdicts on Nehru: The Rise and Fall of A Reputation (e-Single) A collection of short essays, Guha pursues a logical approach to the increasingly toxic messaging on Nehru to separate the wheat from the chaff He acknowledges that some mistakes were made by Nehru but put them in a wider context on what was known at the time He takes each point of criticism and rebuts it Though, I would have preferred longer essays for each of those points. The legacy of Nehru is so vast that it can t be manipulated by false propaganda any party in the veil of Nationalism or inprecise words, jingoism Nehru was, Nehru is and Nehru will remain as the greatest builder of Modern India Certainly he is not God, he had done mistakes, sometimes gross mistakes, but one should think that the situations in which he acted and lead the nation democratically, no other PM of India has ever done. On Jawaharlal Nehru S Th Death Anniversary, Ramachandra Guha Assesses His Place In History, And His Contribution To The Building Of Modern India And Its Democratic Institutions A set of essays evaluating the past popularity of Nehru and the eventual decline of his reputation Considers the view points of later critics of Nehru and critically evaluates each of their viewpoints Also evaluates what could be really termed as his mistakes Some points are fair and some are mere biased suppositions of the author The length of this makes itlike a preface to a book the author never wrote. At the time when once upon a time hero is looked down upon as a villian it s high time we revisit Nehrus legacy In spite of all the missteps he took he is still the best person to be our prime minister during the first 10 years after independence When you say that I would have been a tremendously successful person if my parents would gave brought me up in a better way they did there best during the resources and ideas that were available at that time rings true in case of Nehru alsoBut At the time when once upon a time hero is looked down upon as a villian it s high time we revisit Nehrus legacy In spite of all the missteps he took he is still the best person to be our prime minister during the first 10 years after independence When you say that I would have been a tremendously successful person if my parents would gave brought me up in a better way they did there best during the resources and ideas that were available at that time rings true in case of Nehru alsoBut about the book this isof a superficial discussion on this topic nothing of a scholarly work nor a historical work This is just R Guhas thoughts on our first prime minister Summarily put Why we may be unfair to Nehru in criticizing him over every decision he made The author is unabashed about his admiration of Nehru Good one to read in current times. Often, one generation s outcasts become another generation s hero Owing to the unique place he has in independent India s history as her first and longest serving prime minister, Jawaharlal Nehru s reputation took him in the opposite direction So how did India s most popular statesman for nearly two decades see his reputation being tarnished long after his death Personally, I m an admirer of what Nehru achieved given the circumstances under which he was asked to lead a large nation and its cou Often, one generation s outcasts become another generation s hero Owing to the unique place he has in independent India s history as her first and longest serving prime minister, Jawaharlal Nehru s reputation took him in the opposite direction So how did India s most popular statesman for nearly two decades see his reputation being tarnished long after his death Personally, I m an admirer of what Nehru achieved given the circumstances under which he was asked to lead a large nation and its countless complications in infancy In his objective style, Ramchandra Guha dissects the great man s term with his accomplishments and failures alike to provide his assessment on how the nation fails to recognise it s best ever PM But what makes his critical analysis a fantastic read is his ability to take the reader to an alternate history on occasions and help him formulate his own opinion Here s a sample of what Guha feels Nehru could have done in his time to leave a stronger legacy He could haveactively sought out and nurtured second rung leaders His own preference was for non political types like Homi Bhabha and T.T Krishnamachari people who shared his liberal and cosmopolitan world view However, he did actively try to get brilliant young socialists like Jayaprakash Narayan back to the Congress I think it a real pity that the best, that is, the most intelligent and idealistic of the young Indians, who were then in the socialist and Communist parties, set themselves up in opposition to Nehru Had they worked with him and within the Congress in the 1950s and 1960s, as he asked them to do, they might collectively have ended illiteracy and brought about effective land reforms, which were crucial if India was to progress economically I may not agree with all of Ramchandra Guha s compelling arguments, but after reading Verdicts on Nehru , I m convinced the author is a historian s historian, if there was ever one in India The writer is not hiding the fact that he s already in adoration of Nehru The book is not a detailed account of his life and times butof a scheme of major accusations made against the first prime minister of India Even the majority of things are true but the way of narration in not convincing on factual background Hence I highly doubt wheather we can recommend this book to someone because the risk involved here is probability of backfiring due to narrative style of the writer and admis The writer is not hiding the fact that he s already in adoration of Nehru The book is not a detailed account of his life and times butof a scheme of major accusations made against the first prime minister of India Even the majority of things are true but the way of narration in not convincing on factual background Hence I highly doubt wheather we can recommend this book to someone because the risk involved here is probability of backfiring due to narrative style of the writer and admission of fandom towards Nehru An interesting view of a Nehru fanboy, but totally ignored the indo china war and by large the Kashmir issue for which Nehru is widely chastised for. Nice try to posture the character, but without proper examples and repeating few characteristics throughout the book, but it doesn t seems working Facts are missing throughout the book.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *